Affiliate Marketing Secrets

http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/213-nonstop-gaming-general/63449610?page=49
If you have a Gamefaqs account you should read this.
Do you agree this is how you shouldn’t make an RPG?
1. Lots of playable characters. That is why I dislike Chrono Cross. This creator of this game idea says that is for “Gameplay reasons” but for RPGS Story is more important than gameplay.
2. Non Human Characters. They’re the worst god dammit because they aren’t human.
3. The Creator of this game idea said that some of the idea is Anime inspired. It won’t be so bad but the Creator of that game IS AMERICAN. You can’t make your games anime-like if you’re American. That doesn’t make sense.
4. The Creator of the game idea just doesn’t realize his only potential in life is A FREAKING JANITOR.
5. He is serious on making the game.
6. There is no theme to the game. He said it’s a mix of Fantasy, Modern Day, and sci-fi themes. You should only pick ONE theme.
7. The Creator doesn’t realize this idea will NEVER EVER COME TRUE UNLESS ITS A FIRST PERSON SHOOTER.
8. The Creator has too much creative freedom. Games are made for Gamers, not game developers. I told him to give up ALL OF HIS CREATIVE FREEDOM to make it better.
9. Random characters. This game of his has mechs, mages, parasites that control dead corpses, talking “chain-snakes”, living Jellyfish, puppets, a puppet master, a lizard in an egg, an amnesiac schizo, pyromaniacs, court jesters with bombs, SWAT officers, brains in machines, mole-men with giant tongues, afro samurai’s, Mad scientists, Ghosts, hippies with chainsaws, and a lot of other strange characters. THIS is proof that you should give up Creative Freedom to make a good game.
10. A Long story.
11. A female protagonist. Nowadays those aren’t profitable.
12. The idea is too niche to be profitable
And the Creator got what he deserved by being trolled by half the site to death. No literally everyone was trolling him and wanting him dead.
See? Anyone else agrees that this is how you shouldn’t make a game idea?

I am talking about rpgmaker games usually such as on amaranthgames/bigfish/etc… such as aveyond,eternal eden, and similar things.
I know they aim for the sentimentality of games from the snes era and due to their platform (pc) and small bandwidth size I am sure there is a 20:1 ratio of people who pirate it to purchase it (not exactly 40-gb games here) + the market itself is a niche and comparable quality games are generally offered free anyway.
I just wonder if anyone knows how much any example has brought in and such. I know its not incredibly lucrative but I have a genuine curiosity in it.